Jackie. a immature star with a outstanding voice who gets picked up by a professional recording label after executing at a national endowment competition. Overwhelmed with exhilaration. thinks it is a dream semen true to get down a calling with a moneymaking contract. Meets and has an intimate brush with her shortly to be director. Kevin. Months travel by as their relationship begins to boom but shortly she starts to hear rumours that Kevin has helped a new miss in the legal section acquire her place threw their ain personal dealingss. Jackie has intuitions that Kevin may be holding other deeper interactions with this new miss. Jackie’s intuitions turn out to be true and she is devastated. She evidently breaks off the relationship with Kevin but can non afford to lose him as her director. Time goes by with awkward silence between the two but finally Jackie decides to be professional with her calling and continues to maintain Kevin on as her director.

This lasts for a while until Kevin starts to do inappropriate sexual progresss towards her. She tries to express joy it off but as he continues she threatens to do a formal ailment to legal. He does finally halt but has stopped all attempts to advance her music therefore doing it really hard for her to go on on with her success. She finally does make up one’s mind to do a ailment with legal. there is where she runs into Leslie. the miss that Kevin had got the place for in legal. She tells her. “even I believed you. you didn’t describe this relationship which goes against our superior-employee moralss code” . So either she had the pick to allow the affair go or to do a ailment which would in bend have her besides reprimanded. She is forced with an ultimate determination and finally decides to make nil.

Summarized Ethical Issue at Heart

The unethical issue at bosom is the director. Kevin. doing inappropriate gestures towards Jackie after they had broken up. Making so with Jackie’s vulnerable place of whether or non to describe the issue which would make more injury than good. Or to go forth the affair entirely and merely trust that Kevin would go forth her alone. Neither option are better suited for Jackie who in this instance is the victim. which leads to the inquiry of appropriate ethical duty of the company.

Detailss that are losing in the instance

A 3rd party position on the inside informations of both parties. More item as to what accusals were being made towards Kevin and Jackie. Whether Kevin had proper ethical preparation.

List of all stakeholders who would be involved with this ethical quandary.

Other creative persons
Board of Trustees
Legal Department

Three stakeholders and the concerns they may hold.


Don’t like how they are working for an unethically sound company. Thinking how it could go on to them if they were put in the same state of affairs If the job was of all time made public how would my occupation security expression? Would this company’s name stain my sketch?


How will my portfolio expression if this creative person is to go successful with another manufacturer? Will this narrative go public?
Will my portions plummet from this company’s bad promotion?
What would go on to the company mentality if the full company was to travel thru proper corporate ethical preparation? Could it be a success?

Board of Trustees

This will look bad if the narrative was to made populace
How must will it be to execute proper corporate preparation on proper ethical behaviour? Do the managerial degrees need to be reevaluated?
Could the company be looking at a case?

Five solutions.

Perform corporate preparation at all degrees reexamining proper ethical behavior Fire the director
Workout an unrevealed colony
See if another director is available to take her on
Leave and seek to happen successes elsewhere

Top three solutions with possible effects.

1. Perform corporate preparation at all degrees. proctor it and hold employees subscribe off on modulating constabularies that are being implemented sing superior-employee dealingss every bit good as all other common ethical patterns.

Doesn’t truly work out the job at manus. may be good for the hereafter but doesn’t aid Jackie Company sets public perceptual experience that their ethical criterions are in inquiry Very seasonably and dearly-won
Hazard of employees losing interest/possible turnover of employees

2. Fire and Replace the Manager

May acquire sued by Kevin for unlawful expiration
Jackie’s verbal menaces may go on
Incident is likely to be made public
Board of Trustees would hold to look over all direction places Loss of all positive net incomes that Kevin may hold acquired

3. Workout an unrevealed colony

Sets a criterion for future incorrect behaviors
May non remain quiet
Fellow employees and/or creative person may exert more examination as they mature on with their occupation

Three Stakeholders and Top Three Solutions with two pros and two cons effects on the Stakeholder.

Make company employees take corporate preparation on proper ethical behaviour

Will profit the company’s overall public presentation
Give the media something different to speak about with respects to the company Very dearly-won
Employees may worsen to take it/possible employee turnover

Fire and Replace the Manager

Jackie would be satisfied
The company would hold a bad employee released
Fellow creative persons may lose that label
Manager could action for unlawful expiration

Workout an unrevealed sum

Jackie would be happy and the job would be resolved
Corsets quiet
Solves no hereafter jobs

Two ethical rules upheld or violated by the top three solutions.

Make company employees take corporate preparation on proper ethical behaviour

Provides positive unity to the company
Equally long as the preparation provided was paid hours it shouldn’t be seen in any manner of being unethical Trust and Communication

Fire and Replace the Manager

Fails to run into ethical criterions merely because non adequate information is known Unethical towards the employees as some could all of a sudden be put into a disadvantage

Work out an unrevealed sum

Wholly unethical from the remainder of the company’s point of view as this option would be uneven and serve no intent towards the remainder of the company Financially unethical to utilize financess to function as a colony instead than other intents of the company

Performing corporate preparation at all degrees. monitoring it and hold employees subscribe off on modulating constabularies that are being implemented sing superior-employee dealingss every bit good as all other common ethical patterns will supply positive unity to the company. If the preparation hours were paid and it didn’t have an consequence on day-to-day modus operandi so it doesn’t look to be unethical to bespeak preparation hours. Open firing the director Kevin would work out Jackie’s job but lone hers entirely. To be just which is a rule of moralss would be to implement a codification that would profit the company as a whole. Although what Kevin is accused of making is warranted of being fired there merely isn’t adequate information for the company to allow him travel. Her words against his wouldn’t be adequate to fire him. This is why a revamp of full corporate preparation likely stands to be the best possible solution for this state of affairs.

Decision and Execution

Identify the best solution.

Implementing corporate preparation throughout the full staff of the company possibly specialising in specific countries would be most likely to be the best possible solution. There are a batch more benefits to educating employees on proper moralss. A workplace in which an morals codification has been instilled is a of course pleasant topographic point. Employee morale rises in an ambiance that promotes good behaviour and honorable interactions.

Reasons why this is the best solution.

It creates a better ambiance in the workplace. Teachs an office how to work as a squad. promotes personal duty. and has ever shown to hike staff morale. A work moralss developing plan promotes teamwork by transfusing trust in colleagues. Peoples are more likely to be conformable to working together when they appreciate and respect one another.

Why the other solutions were rejected

Open firing the director Kevin every bit good as doing an unrevealed colony were found to be unethical towards other members of the company. It would non be a good illustration to put if the company were to individual out an incident and act in an irregular manner towards that issue. There besides wasn’t adequate facts to the instance to do the determination to fire the director. Kevin. Particularly making so cognizing full well it would impact other stakeholders.

Possible expostulations to the solution

The company may happen that employee may kick that they do non necessitate to take portion in preparation. A compulsory demand may necessitate to be implemented for all employees. A turnover rate within the employees may be seen. Investors or Board of Trustees will look at all avenues of the cheapest method of implementing preparation.

How would you get the better of these expostulations?

Make it a demand to achieve a certain figure of moralss developing hours. Find other avenues of support that can lend to the plan to do certain that employees are having the best preparation. Self-inflicted preparation from the managerial degree is a cheaper method to teach employees.


Ethical Dilemma. ( n. d. ) . Forbes. Retrieved. from hypertext transfer protocol: //www. forbes. com/2004/06/23/cx_da_0623topnews. hypertext markup language

Advantages of Training Employees About Work Ethics. ( n. d. ) . Small Business. Retrieved. from hypertext transfer protocol: //smallbusiness. chron. com/advantages-training-employees-work-ethics-44472. hypertext markup language

Ethical motives Training in the Workplace. ( n. d. ) . Ethical motives Training. Retrieved. from hypertext transfer protocol: //www. rctm. com/ethics. htm

Institute For Ethical Awareness. ( n. d. ) . Institute For Ethical Awareness. Retrieved. from hypertext transfer protocol: //www. instituteforethicalawareness. org

The Online Business Ethics Training Program | Ethics Training Guide. ( n. d. ) . Ethical motives Training Guide. Retrieved. from hypertext transfer protocol: //ethicstrainingguide. org/

Written by

I'm Colleen!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out