With football season getting started, I was reminded of my first post here at the Two-Gun blog, “Post Oaks and Football.” In that post, I talked about how accurate the opening scene of Howard’s semi-autobiographical novel Post Oaks and Sand Roughs is. This got me thinking, so I pulled the Grant edition from the shelf and read the chapter again. The following conversation between Steve Costigan (Howard) and Clive Hilton (Tevis Clyde Smith), which takes place right after the football game discussed in my first post, grabbed my attention:
“That was sure a great run Franey made, wasnt it?” remarked Steve.“Yes, it was,” Clive acquiesced.“Guess you’re here writing the game up for The Rattler?”“Yes.
I guess the student body’ll read it, on account of Franey.”[. . .]“I guess I’ll have the title lines in ten point type,” Clive said suddenly. “I think I’ll try a new style for the front page this week. The students won’t know the difference but a man appreciates his own work.”
Given how accurate Howard’s description of the football game had been in this fictional work, I wondered if he had played fast and loose with the post-game conversation or kept mostly to the facts.
Luckily, I had a way to fact check it.At Texas A&M’s Cushing Memorial Library and Archives, they’ve got Smith’s collection of The Tattler, including the edition that came out right after the November 27, 1924 game between Howard Payne and Simmons. Both of my questions are answered on the front page.First, “Clive” says he’s writing an article about the game for the paper. In the “real world,” Clyde Smith was editor-in-chief of The Tattler for the 1923-24 school year.
The paper’s staff box does not list a sport’s editor, so I guess we can’t be certain who wrote the following story, but my money’s on Clyde:After that, “Clive” says he’s going to experiment with a new style for the paper that week. Clyde Smith did exactly that:Written in 1928, Post Oaks and Sand Roughs is presented as fiction, but it’s sure got a lot of fact included. If nothing else, this underlines how good Howard’s memory was. I can’t remember a conversation from last week, nevermind four years go.