Punishment Essay, Research Paper

Punishment, by Rabindranath Tagore, is a short narrative affecting Indian civilization and a quandary for two brothers. Dukhiram and Chidam slaved in the Fieldss all twenty-four hours, as their married womans would contend and shout at each other at the house. One twenty-four hours the brothers came home to their married womans with no nutrient expecting them. Dukhiram, ferocious and enraged, asked his married woman where the nutrient was. Radha, his married woman, said sardonically, & # 8221 ; Where is the nutrient? You didn & # 8217 ; t give me anything to cook. Must I earn the money myself to purchase it? & # 8221 ; ( Punishment, pg.1451 ) After a difficult yearss work, Dukhiram couldn & # 8217 ; t manage the sarcasim. So he stabbed Radha in the caput with his knife. In the mean while, Ramlochan, the pillar of the small town, came to roll up rent from the brothers. He walked in the house and witnessed Dukhiram sobbing in the corner. Chidam rushed over and explained the recent events to the Ramlochan. Since Ramlochan was the adult male who took attention of legal affairs, he decided to assist Chidam. They both decided it would be best to put the incrimination on Chidam & # 8217 ; s married woman, Chandara. Chidam did non wish to lose his brother, and he felt he could do up a narrative to unclutter his married woman from the charges anyways. Word of the slaying spread around town and shortly the constabulary came to inquiry Chandara. Chidam had instructed her to state that Radha attacked her with a slicer, and she reacted in self-defence. However, Chandara told the constabulary the antonym. She said that Radha didn & # 8217 ; t assail her in any manner. Chidam, perfectly shocked, couldn & # 8217 ; t believe what his married woman had said. She continued to squeal her guilt to all who questioned her. The instance so went to test, where one time once more she pronounced her actions of slaying. Chidam was questioned after her, and he confessed that he had killed Radha. However, the justice didn & # 8217 ; t believe him. He concluded that the brothers were merely seeking to salvage Chandara. So she was sentenced to decease by hanging.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

The relationship between the narrative and Indian civilization is really important and apparent in the author & # 8217 ; s narrative. One important facet of the narrative was the relationship between work forces and adult females. Indian civilization by and large discriminates on adult females. India & # 8217 ; s chief web site said that immature misss have it m

uch harder than male childs, holding to make much more jobs and undertakings, and the “discrimination doesn’t terminal with adulthood” ( www.Asianinfo.org ) .

This facet of Indian civilization was apparent in this narrative through a few illustrations. First, the married womans both stayed place and cleaned the house, Radha looked after her boy, and they cooked the nutrient. They were besides treated inferior by their hubbies. An illustration of this is when Dukiram comes place demanding and anticipating nutrient from his married woman. He treated her like he was the foreman or as if he was more of import than her. Last, Chandara volitionally accepts her hubby & # 8217 ; s bespeak to squeal the offense. This indicates that adult females back so viewed theirselves as being inferior to work forces because of the manner Indian civilization taught them.

The other culturally important portion of the narrative had to make with household imposts. & # 8220 ; Family is of import in India, and it is what their lives are centered around & # 8221 ; ( www.Asianinfo.org ) . An illustration from the narrative is when Chidam becomes really disquieted and scared when he realizes his brother will decease for his offense. He says to Ramlochan, & # 8221 ; If I lose my married woman I can acquire another, but if my brother is hanged, how can I replace him? & # 8221 ; ( Punishment, pg1453 ) This statement implies that immediate household is more of import. Siblings were more of import and more valued than married womans were in Indian civilization, for Chidam was willing to lose his married woman in order to maintain his brother alive.

In decision, it is interesting to detect the cultural significance this narrative has. Tagore wrote this narrative based on his cultural experience in India. Small pieces of the narrative point to the manner of Indian life and values. Coming from another civilization, it wasn & # 8217 ; t excessively difficult to calculate out what Indian imposts were like after reading this book. So Tagore, in my sentiment, did an first-class occupation of supplying the reader with a basic apprehension of how relationships between work forces and adult females existed during his clip.


Family Customss in India. www.asianinfo.org/asianinfo/india/pro-family_customs.htm. Asianinfo.org, 2000.

Social Issues in India. www.indiagov.org/social/menu.htm. Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India, 2001.

Written by

I'm Colleen!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out