Although “To an Athlete Dying Young” by A. E. Housman and “Ex-Basketball Player” by John Updike are both about the contemplation of honorary illustriousness achieved in their lives as jocks. the talkers possess different positions and attitudes towards their characters in each verse form. In “To an Athlete Dying Young” the talker portions a positive contemplation of the characters achievements that takes topographic point due to the decease of that character deceasing at a immature age: “To-day. the route all smugglers come. / Shoulder-high we bring you place. /And put you at your threshold down. /Townsman of a stiller town. ” ( “Athlete”5-8 ) . In “Ex-Basketball Player” John Updike talker reflects upon Flick Webb’s past accomplishments in the as a high school hoops participant: “Once Flick played for the high-school squad. the Wizards / He was good: in fact. the best. ” ( “Ex-Basketball”13-14 ) . Though the talker praises Flick Webb’s on his past accomplishments as an jock. the talker sets a tone of a adult male that has non achieved much during his grownup old ages: “He ne’er learned a trade. he merely sells gas. / Checks oil. and alterations flats. ” ( “Ex-Basketball”19-20 ) .

The image painted with words by the talker in “To an Athlete Dying Young” portrays a narrative of an athlete receiving congratulations and award for their life and achievements achieved. Housman’s talker describes the early decease of the deceased as: “Smart chap. to steal early off / From Fieldss where glorification does non stay” ( “Athlete” 9-10 ) . Throughout the verse form. the talker gives praised to the deceased by demoing his grasp and award that he holds for immature deceased athlete: “The clip you won your town the race / We chaired you through the market-place ; / Man and boy stood shouting by. ( “Athlete”1-3 ) . “Now you will non swell the mob / Of chaps that wore their awards out. ” ( “Athlete”17-18 ) . The talker positively reminisces about the athlete life and achievements. The speaker’s words paint a image that the jock did so die immature but that his achievements will everlastingly be a bequest. Housman’s talker straight addresses the jock to demo regard and award to the asleep achievements.

The speaker’s regard and esteem for the asleep jock in “To an Athlete Dying Young” is face-to-face from the talker in “Ex-Basketball Player” by John Updike. positions about Flick Webb. The talker describes the life narrative of Flick Webb. an old high school jock who was singular who is now merely a gas station attender: “Once Flick played for the high-school squad. the Wizards / He was good: in fact. the best. ” ( “Ex-Basketball”13-14 ) . “At Colonel McComsky Plaza. Berth’s Garage / Is on the corner confronting west. and at that place. / Most yearss. you’ll find Flick Webb. who helps Berth out. ” ( “Ex-Basketball”4-6 ) . The speaker’s attitude towards Flick Webb sets a tone of deficiency of motive and letdown: “Flick bases tall among the idiot pumps-” ( “Ex-Basketball”7 ) . The talker believes that Flick’s possible and endowments should hold assisted more towards him going successful alternatively of merely being a gas station attender. “He ne’er learned a trade. he merely sells gas. / Checks oil. and alterations flats. ” ( “Ex-Basketball”19-20 ) .

In both verse forms. the talkers give congratulations to the athletes’ achievements in athleticss. expressed in lines: “The clip you won your town the race / We chaired you through the market-place ; / Man and boy stood shouting by. / And place we brought you shoulder-high. ” ( “Athlete”1-4 ) . “Once Flick played for the high-school squad. the Wizards / He was good: in fact. the best. In ’46 /He bucketed three hundred 90 points. / A county record still. The ball loved Flick. / I saw him single-foot up thirty-eight or 40 / In one place game. / His custodies were like wild birds. ” ( “Ex-Basketball”13-18 ) . Both talkers had a utmost grasp for the jocks craft in athleticss. In contrast. Housman’s talker revealed positive ideas and contemplation of the asleep jock.

The talker held really high respects for the asleep jock and felt that the athlete’s achievements and life will everlastingly be remembered by the talker. Although the talker in “Ex-Basketball Player” did hold an grasp and involvements for Flick’s strenuosity. the talker every bit good held a feeling of letdown for Flick. With flick being such a great jock. made the talker believe that more could hold been achieved by Flick during his life alternatively of merely being a gas station attender.

Updike. John. “Ex-Basketball Player. ”Literature: an debut to fiction. poesy. play. and composing. 10th erectile dysfunction. . synergistic erectile dysfunction. New York: Pearson Longman. 2007. 879-880.

Housman. A. E. . “To an Athlete Dying Young. ” Literature: an debut to fiction. poesy. play. and composing. 10th erectile dysfunction. . synergistic erectile dysfunction. New York: Pearson Longman. 2007. 849-850.

Written by
admin
x

Hi!
I'm Colleen!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out